Gather 'round the campfire
Jul. 12th, 2011 10:52 am![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
Pull up a seat, and have some s'mores. Let's talk AU.
I love AUs. One of the great things about them is that they open up a whole new range of maladies and misfortunes to inflict on Our Heroes. There are stories set far in the future or past, supernatural stories with vampires and werewolves, sci-fi stories with robots and fantasy stories with demons and angels. Are there kind of AUs you like and ones you don't (for instance, maybe you love historical stories but hate ones with a supernatural element)? Do you hate the entire genre?
As a side question, I've always been curious what readers perceive as an AU and what they don't. Most ratings seem to be based on the setting more than anything else. If the setting is canon but Wilson is a woman, is that AU? What if someone is a shape-changer, or a telepath, or the story includes weird mystical powers, zombies or mpreg, is that AU? If House and Wilson appear exactly as in canon but are practicing medicine in a field hospital in Afghanistan, is that AU? Where, in other words, are the boundaries? Is all fanfiction a kind of AU and it's just a matter of degree?
I love AUs. One of the great things about them is that they open up a whole new range of maladies and misfortunes to inflict on Our Heroes. There are stories set far in the future or past, supernatural stories with vampires and werewolves, sci-fi stories with robots and fantasy stories with demons and angels. Are there kind of AUs you like and ones you don't (for instance, maybe you love historical stories but hate ones with a supernatural element)? Do you hate the entire genre?
As a side question, I've always been curious what readers perceive as an AU and what they don't. Most ratings seem to be based on the setting more than anything else. If the setting is canon but Wilson is a woman, is that AU? What if someone is a shape-changer, or a telepath, or the story includes weird mystical powers, zombies or mpreg, is that AU? If House and Wilson appear exactly as in canon but are practicing medicine in a field hospital in Afghanistan, is that AU? Where, in other words, are the boundaries? Is all fanfiction a kind of AU and it's just a matter of degree?